Well, that's one mystery solved. It's now clear that 123 does not equal 126. For all those who believed that India had shackled itself to the US aerospace industry after the nuclear deal, this week's decision to dump the US fighters in favour of European ones should be a relief.
India is spreading the love around. Russians used to be king in the Indian defence market, until they succumbed to the lure of the Chinese and their technology was becoming dated. After it became clear the Chinese were knocking off MiGs and Sukhois for Pakistan and Russia could do absolutely nothing about it, India backed away from Moscow's vulnerabilities. Israel, the US, France all have a big presence on the Indian horizon now.
The Americans, according to most technical assessments, pitched two not-so-new aircraft for India. At a rarefied level, the differences between the world's top-line aircraft is minimal, so what tilts the balance are extraneous factors. For instance, there was never any hope that Indians would buy the same fighters that Pakistan has, even if India had got a more evolved version. India would have wanted access to the US' enviable avionics, radar systems, beyond visual range capabilities etc.
But little of the top-line stuff would be available to India and almost all of it would come with far too much intrusive baggage, including end-user verification, restrictive export control laws etc, which would make things very difficult. The US still hasn't quite got its head around the fact that on many things India likes to play solo. Actually, if the US had offered a role in the joint strike fighter, then it could have been a sweet deal.
Left to himself, PM Manmohan Singh would have probably found a way to get the US in, because he believes it's important to get the US invested in India's defence sector in the longer term. But in the poisonous political environment in the upper echelons of the government, defence minister Antony won the day making technical grounds supreme.
The Eurofighter (if that's the one India ultimately chooses ) apparently comes with a more attractive technology transfer and offsets policy. India needs to develop manufacturing capability and fast. Since it cannot match China in mass manufacturing, India needs to get on top of the highend manufacturing sector for its economic growth to be a strategic tool going forward.
That, India has decided, is best done with the Germans and Italians. Bernhard Gerwert, head of EADS (which makes Eurofighter) said in an interview, "Look at the strategic partnership which we offer to the Indian customer and the Indian industry. EADS Defence & Security just launched a joint venture with Larsen & Toubro. What are we planning to do? We will transfer technology from Germany to India. We will transfer workload from Germany to India. The products which will be produced in the first step of this joint venture are not related to the Eurofighter. However, we can use this technology later for the Eurofighter. " This could happen in the field of avionics too. This is also one reason why India and Israel are such a natural fit. However, the Eurofighter, while possibly a great product, is not a tested one. Its first combat experience is ironically, in Libya. Reports from there are mixed. And we will all have to pay a heck of a lot more for the aircraft.
The MMRCA deal was always going to be a strategic one. The question is what strategy has India decided to invest in. The aircraft or the relationship? I believe India has the aircraft in its sights. On the relationship, it is to be hoped that India will manage the US better. It's doubtful, because the system finds it so hard to acknowledge the importance of the US in India's strategic matrix. Certainly, we should have informed them of the decision in advance out of courtesy if nothing else.
The US can, in its pique, make it a lot more difficult for us to get into the global non-proliferation regimes as retaliation for the MMRCA decision. Barack Obama too is a transactional leader and he could conclude that India is no longer a good bargain. That will be a setback. But the sense seems to be, there's life beyond a fighter aircraft. It's possible that the extraneous problems accompanying an American aircraft could consume the relationship.
No comments:
Post a Comment